Category: False Report

I’m glad to report that Ultramontanists do not exist.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • April 15, 2024 • False Report; papacy

 

Ultra­mon­tanists are like the bogey­man: a myth­i­cal being used to fright­en chil­dren. Thus at The Catholic Thing, Fr. Jef­frey Kir­by warns his read­ers about “the rise of the Ultra­mon­tanists.” You nev­er know when the bogey­man is going to come and get you; you nev­er know when the Ultra­mon­tanist is going to wreck the Church. It’s an always-present dan­ger. I have very fre­quent­ly been accused of being an Ultra­mon­tanist, for no oth­er rea­son than that I defend the pope and believe the Holy Spir­it safe­guards the Church from ever teach­ing error. Thus when­ev­er I see an arti­cle like this one, the first thing I do is check whether the author defines what an Ultra­mon­tanist is. Not every­one who uses the term does; it’s a dis­ser­vice to the read­er.

Read more

“The Collapse of Dave Armstrong.”

BY: Scott Eric Alt • January 12, 2023 • False Report; On Other Blogs

 

For­give my title; they’re not my words, but David Griffey’s. In his post on Jan­u­ary 9, Mr. Grif­fey tells us that it’s a new year, and in this new year he’s grown tired of blog­ging about issues and pol­i­tics. He, Mr. Grif­fey, is “no writer,” he says. He’s not “invest­ed” in it. But Mark Shea, once upon a time before he became a mean and angry heretic, sug­gest­ed that Grif­fey start a blog; and Grif­fey did; and his blog took off, even though it involved a lot of hit­ting his head against a brick wall. He want­ed to quit many times, but polit­i­cal con­tro­ver­sy drew him back in—and a pity too, because polit­i­cal con­tro­ver­sy amounts to noth­ing more than peo­ple call­ing each oth­er Hitler. And after explain­ing all this to us in a remark­able ram­ble, Grif­fey final­ly gets around to talk­ing about—who else?—Dave Arm­strong!

Read more

Crisis!!! plays Benedict vs. Francis on Amoris Laetitia.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • May 16, 2019 • Amoris Laetitia; False Report

 

Richard A. Spinel­lo, author of a recent arti­cle at Cri­sis!!!, goes as far as to claim that the pope emeritus’s let­ter on the sex abuse cri­sis was an “implic­it rebuke” of Amor­is Laeti­tia. Odd, then, that the Vat­i­can gave the green light to B16. How very care­less of Frank, to miss his sub­text this way. But Spinel­lo sees all, even though “Bene­dict is quite dis­crete, of course, and nev­er men­tions Amor­is Laeti­tia.” It all has the tone of wish­ful think­ing on Spinello’s part. And I say that because Spinel­lo accus­es Pope Fran­cis of deny­ing what the text explic­it­ly affirms.

Read more

Kwasniewski, Fr. Murray, Death Site News promote falsehoods on capital punishment.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • August 4, 2018 • Blind Guides & False Prophets; False Report; Pro-Life Issues

 

Fr. Mur­ray is mys­ti­fied: On Ray­mond P.W. Arroy­o’s anti-Fran­cis pro­pa­gan­da show The World Over, he says he has no idea why the pope would think the death penal­ty vio­lates the dig­ni­ty of the human per­son. Pos­si­bly Pope Fran­cis might think so because Pope St. John Paul II had already said it him­self. It’s in Evan­geli­um Vitae. Per­haps Mur­ray has read it; though, I begin to won­der whether he mere­ly skimmed it for the parts about abor­tion. What­ev­er the case might be, JP2 explains to us why God pro­tect­ed Cain from the death penal­ty.

Read more

Pope Francis contradicts Benedict XVI and John Paul II on abortion? Fake (Site) News!

BY: Scott Eric Alt • April 11, 2018 • False Report; Pope Francis; Pro-Life Issues

 

I tell you again: Give no cre­dence to Fake Site News. Nev­er give them cre­dence, but par­tic­u­lar­ly give them no cre­dence when they are bash­ing the pope. Nev­er give them cre­dence when they are bash­ing the pope, but par­tic­u­lar­ly give them no cre­dence when the author is John-Hen­ry West­en. A look at his absurd attempt, here, to claim that Pope Fran­cis some­how con­tra­dicts Bene­dict XVI and John Paul II on abor­tion, gives us one more exam­ple why. But first let us go to Gaudete et Exsul­tate and read the words of Pope Fran­cis about the equal sacred­ness of all human life.

Read more

Fake Site News accuses New Pro Life Movement of “liberal boilerplate.”

BY: Scott Eric Alt • September 16, 2017 • Church Social Teaching; False Report; Pro-Life Issues

 

In a shame­less piece of char­ac­ter assas­si­na­tion against Rebec­ca Brat­ten Weiss, Fake Site News made the aston­ish­ing claim that the goals of the New Pro Life Move­ment are no more than “lib­er­al boil­er­plate.” In fact, every one of them comes from the Mag­is­te­r­i­al teach­ing of the Church. Has Fake Site not read the Com­pendi­um of the Social Doc­trine of the Church? Evan­geli­um Vitae? Lauda­to Si? The Church’s teach­ing on just war? The very Cat­e­chism? Maybe they should get on that, rather than writ­ing sin­ful hit pieces against good and decent Catholics like Rebec­ca Brat­ten Weiss.

Read more

Reports of the death of Humanae Vitae are greatly exaggerated.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • September 13, 2017 • False Report

 

Can we please take a look at what Pope Fran­cis has actu­al­ly said about Humanae Vitae? For in Amor­is Laeti­tia we find him say­ing that mar­riage is ordered, “by its very nature,” toward pro­cre­ation. “Open­ness to life is the con­di­tion of the sacra­ment of mat­ri­mo­ny,” the pope says else­where. And yet I am sup­posed to believe the pope is on the verge of over­throw­ing Paul VI’s encycli­cal But it turns out Edward Pentin at the Reg­is­ter is bent on reviv­ing these rumors, always with the melo­dra­ma, anony­mous sources, pained expres­sions, and stage whis­pers.

Read more

Oh, that conference on deposing a pope? Church Miscreant had it wrong. And Fake Site News.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • April 4, 2017 • False Report

 

Last month our friends at Church Mis­cre­ant were all jit­tery at the news that there would be a con­fer­ence in Paris on how to depose a pope. Canon lawyers, Chris­tine Niles gushed, would be there! You know, actu­al canon lawyers, who might advise on how to get rid of that pesky Bergoglio. Two peo­ple sched­uled to speak at the con­fer­ence even signed a let­ter cri­tiquing Amor­is Laeti­tia! Anoth­er sup­ported the dubia! Fake Site News tried to make the same con­nec­tion. Turns out, it was noth­ing of the kind. Wrong again at Fake Site and Mis­cre­ant; what a shock.

Read more

Don’t believe this fake Pius IX quotation on a pope teaching heresy.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • March 22, 2017 • False Report

 

If a future pope teach­es some­thing con­trary to the Catholic faith, don’t fol­low him.” Trads who pro­mote dis­sent from Pope Fran­cis claim Pius IX said this in a let­ter to “Bish­op Brizen.” One glar­ing prob­lem: There has nev­er been a bish­op by that name, still less dur­ing the reign of Pius IX. Oops. Now, there is a Roman Catholic dio­cese of Brix­en. Per­haps this is where the con­fu­sion is. Per­haps Pius IX wrote the let­ter to the “bish­op of Brix­en.” Well, the bish­op of Brix­en dur­ing the reign of Pius IX was Vin­cent Fer­rer Gasser. He wrote a Rela­tio for Vat­i­can I on papal infal­li­bil­i­ty.

Read more

Oh, that story about Pope Francis advocating population control …

BY: Scott Eric Alt • March 7, 2017 • False Report; Pope Francis

 

It was based on a mis­quo­ta­tion of Vat­i­can pan­elist Peter Raven. See, I told you so. The pope was advo­cat­ing “sus­tain­abil­i­ty,” but “respon­si­ble par­ent­hood,” which the last three popes—Benedict XVI, John Paul II, and Paul VI—also advo­cat­ed. Many were out­raged when the pope said that Catholics should not feel they must “breed like rab­bits” in order to be good Catholics. Some mis­quot­ed the pope as hav­ing com­mand­ed: “Don’t breed like rab­bits.” You need to be care­ful about these mis­quo­ta­tions. The pope tells us what the Church has already told us.

Read more

Attn. Fox News, et al.: The pope has condemned population control.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • March 5, 2017 • False Report; Pope Francis

 

Fox News, the UK Inde­pen­dent, and LSD News are all report­ing that the pope has praised pop­u­la­tion con­trol. This is fake news. And the rea­son I say so is because Pope Fran­cis is on record con­demn­ing pop­u­la­tion con­trol. He con­demns it in Lauda­to Si—have you read it? Even LSD News and the Nation­al Catholic Reg­is­ter picked up on that. He con­demned it in his inter­view on the flight back to Rome from Mani­la; maybe you recall that inter­view. Did you know he con­demns pop­u­la­tion con­trol in that inter­view three times? I have all the quotes, dear read­er.

Read more

Pope Francis corrects Pope Francis; will media correct media?

BY: Scott Eric Alt • June 21, 2016 • False Report; Pope Francis

 

Here is a good rule of thumb. When some­one says, “I mis­spoke, here is what I meant to say”: Believe him. Mis­s­peak­ing is a known phe­nom­e­non. If you haven’t known about this phe­nom­e­non for some time, I don’t know what you know. Even popes can mis­s­peak. It’s true. I have checked, and rechecked, the dog­mat­ic def­i­n­i­tion of papal infal­li­bil­i­ty, and I find nowhere that the Holy Spir­it pro­tects the Roman Pon­tiff from mis­s­peak­ing. Check it your­self if you like, but do not waste too much of your time. That’s what I’m here for.

Read more

Now, if Life Site News could correct the record. (Again.)

BY: Scott Eric Alt • May 2, 2016 • Amoris Laetitia; False Report

 

Wouldn’t it be prop­er to explain that, accord­ing to Schon­born — the man Pope Fran­cis says has the right under­stand­ing about com­mu­nion for the divorced and remar­ried — AL is actu­al­ly to be read in har­mo­ny with FC 84,? Wouldn’t it clear up a lot of poten­tial con­fu­sion to say, Now, Schon­born spec­i­fies that the “cer­tain cas­es” in are those which the cou­ple has agreed to prac­tice celiba­cy? The very sec­tion of FC 84 that Mr. West­en quot­ed to show that Amor­is is a depar­ture, was Schon­born quot­ed to explain how Amor­is is con­sis­tent.

Read more

Life Site News gets a pope story wrong. (Again.)

BY: Scott Eric Alt • April 19, 2016 • Amoris Laetitia; False Report

 

In this lat­est exam­ple of errant reportage, Life Site News pro­claims: “Pope Says Schon­born Inter­pre­ta­tion on Com­mu­nion is the Final Word”! (That’s the title.) Now, I looked at the pope’s inter­view; can’t recall the pope say­ing any­thing that can fair­ly be sum­ma­rized as defer­ring to Schon­born the “final word.” Nor was Schonborn’s pre­sen­ta­tion of Amor­is Laeti­tia, quite exact­ly, an “inter­pre­ta­tion” of any sort. It was, rather, a sum­ma­ry of the pope’s exhor­ta­tion; I find it to be very pro­fuse with direct quo­ta­tions. So we shall have to dis­cern very care­ful­ly to see whether West­ern or I has it right.

Read more

Pope gives another interview; false reporting begins at 1 Vader 5 forthwith.

BY: Scott Eric Alt • April 16, 2016 • Amoris Laetitia; False Report

 

Mr. Steve Sko­jec, of 1 Vad­er 5 infamy, was quick to pounce, claws unsheathed, on the lat­est papal inter­view. He did so in order to make the self-affirm­ing claim that Pope Fran­cis gave an unam­bigu­ous, full-throat­ed “Yes!” to com­mu­nion for the divorced and remar­ried. Shaz­a­am. The pope, says Mr. Sko­jec, gave “a very straight­for­ward affir­ma­tion” in response to a “very direct ques­tion” from a reporter. “Straight­for­ward,” you say? “Very direct,” you say? Then let us hie our­selves to the text of that inter­view and take a look.

Read more