Msgr. Kevin Irwin’s bizarre attempt to call belief in Eucharistic miracles “heresy.”

BY: Henry Matthew Alt • November 5, 2021 • Apologetics; Sacraments; The Eucharist

 

At the Nation­al Catholic Reporter, Msgr. Irwin is exer­cised by the bish­ops’ draft doc­u­ment The Mys­tery of the Eucharist in the Life of the Church. His main con­cern is that the lan­guage of the doc­u­ment is too out­mod­ed; “it reflects 400-year-old the­ol­o­gy,” he says, rather than devel­op­ments since Vat­i­can II. It uses musty words like “tran­sub­stan­ti­a­tion”; it insists on obscure dis­tinc­tions between “venial” and “mor­tal” sin; it uses the term “Real Pres­ence,” for Jesus’ sake! “Are these terms,” Msgr. won­ders, “aimed at peo­ple who no longer attend Mass,” or are they aimed instead at the bish­ops them­selves?

Read more